Why I Don’t Believe in Eschatology
Douglas Witherup
Okay, confession time: the title is a little clickbaity. But I also really do mean it. And I think it matters. Here’s why.
First off, let’s clarify: the word eschatology is not in the Bible. That’s not necessarily a problem. After all, neither is the word Trinity, and that doctrine is foundational to the Christian faith. And just because Christmas trees don’t appear in Scripture doesn’t mean having one in your living room is wrong. (Unless it’s February. Then it’s very wrong. Take it down. Seriously.)
But back to the point — eschatology, as a term, didn’t exist in the vocabulary of early Christians. It wasn’t introduced until around the 17th century, during the rise of post-Reformation theology in Europe. The word gained real traction in the 19th century, especially among Protestant systematic theologians.
Again, the problem isn’t the word’s late arrival. The issue is the meaning it carries.
Eschatology = “The Study of the End”
The word combines:
- Eschatos = last, final
- -logy = the study of
So, eschatology quite literally means “the study of last things” or “the end times.”
But here’s where I push back: Revelation isn’t the end.
It’s not a wrap-up or a closing chapter.
It’s a re-beginning.
It’s Eden restored. The garden becoming a garden-city. The curse removed. Heaven and earth reunited. It’s not the end — it’s the again.
And sure, I realize this might sound like a matter of semantics. But let’s not forget: semantics shape theology, and theology shapes how we live.
If my framework is built around endings, I live clinging to this world. I fear death. I avoid Revelation because it seems scary and unfamiliar. But if my theology is rooted in re-beginnings, then I’m filled with hope. I long for a better land. I ache — in the best way — for the ultimate homecoming.
A Better Word and a Better Way: Palingenesiology
Let me humbly propose an alternative: palingenesiology.
It's built on the Greek word παλιγγενεσία (palingenesia), meaning rebirth or regeneration.
- Palin = again
- Genesia = birth or genesis
It appears in Matthew 19:28, where Jesus promises “the renewal of all things.” This word captures not just the personal transformation of salvation, but a cosmic one — the full-scale renewal of everything broken.
Palingenesiology = the study of new beginnings.
The study of Genesis again.
The study of Eden again.
The study of a restored world where Christ is King, the curse is no more, and all things are made new.
So Let Me Ask You:
Would you rather study a theology of endings that feels fearful and heavy? Or a theology of re-beginnings that breathes life and hope into every part of your soul?
Me?
I’ll take
palingenesiology — every time.
Why Christians’ Involvement at the Gate of Government Is Not Christian Nationalism Dismantling the Lies That Keep Christians, Pastors, and Churches from Engaging at the Gate of Government My Story I’ll admit it — I had fallen for the lies. At nineteen, I was a student at a conservative evangelical Pentecostal college. It was an incredible environment — chapels filled with the Holy Spirit, professors who genuinely cared for their students, deep theological training, and lifelong friendships. But no college is perfect. Just like there’s no perfect church, family, or person. As a naive young man studying for ministry, I absorbed everything I was taught. A few professors, however, began subtly introducing ideas like: America was inherently racist. The Founding Fathers weren’t really Christians — they were Deists — so our foundations weren’t truly Judeo-Christian. Evangelical Christians had fallen into “Christian Nationalism,” trying to establish God’s Kingdom politically in America. The worst part? These ideas were wrapped in Bible verses and presented as “the real truth,” making young, impressionable students question their upbringing, their churches, and their faith. It took me years to realize what I had been taught wasn’t true. Still wounded, I spent the next fifteen years convinced pastors and churches should steer clear of anything that even appeared political. But over time, through Scripture and prayer, I regained both my theological footing and my voice. It all began with one crucial shift — a truth I’ll unpack in this first blog. The Primary Theological Shift The biggest lie keeping Christians, pastors, and churches from engaging at the Gate of Government is the accusation of “Christian Nationalism.” The claim goes something like this: “Jesus wasn’t political, and you shouldn’t be either. You’re trying to make America the new Israel and turn the gospel into a political kingdom.” In this model, the picture looks like this:
In Acts 19 , we see a striking contrast between the ministry of Paul and the ministry of the Seven Sons of Sceva . Paul walked in true spiritual authority —demons fled, the sick were healed, and Jesus was exalted. The Sons of Sceva, however, while recognized and itinerant in ministry, lacked the substance of power. They had platform , but not presence . They had recognition , but not revelation . They tried to confront darkness, but darkness confronted them. There is a line being drawn today —not just between the world and the church, but between the true church and those who merely perform religion . The difference? Authority. And Jesus tells us how we receive it: “This kind does not go out except by prayer and fasting.” — Matthew 17:21 As Keenan Clark says: “God unlocks things for those who fast that He does not unlock for those who don’t.” Years ago, I read Fasting for Spiritual Breakthrough by Dr. Elmer Towns , based on Isaiah 58 —God’s blueprint for fasting that produces real power. Below is that foundation, expanded and adapted. As you read, ask the Holy Spirit: What are You calling me to fast for? The 12 Biblical Fasts (from Isaiah 58) 1. The Disciple’s Fast – Breaking Bondage & Generational Curses Isaiah 58: “To loose the bonds of wickedness” (v. 6a) “I will feed you with the heritage of Jacob your father” (v. 14c) “You shall raise up the foundations of many generations” (v. 12b) Purpose: Break sin patterns, addictions, and generational strongholds—shifting your spiritual inheritance and blessing future generations. 2. The Ezra Fast – For Guidance and Solutions “To undo the heavy burdens .” (v. 6b) Scripture: Ezra 8:21–23 Purpose: Seek God’s wisdom when facing overwhelming decisions or challenges. 3. The Samuel Fast – For Revival and Awakening “To let the oppressed go free .” (v. 6c) “And your ancient ruins shall be rebuilt… restorer of streets to dwell in .” (v. 12) Purpose: Intercession for the lost and revival in homes, churches, and cities. 4. The Elijah Fast – To Break Fear, Depression, and Discouragement “To undo the straps of the yoke .” (v. 6d) “Then you shall take delight in the Lord .” (v. 14a) Scripture: 1 Kings 19:4–8 Purpose: Replace emotional heaviness with renewed joy and strength. 5. The Widow’s Fast – Releasing Provision through Compassion “To share your bread with the hungry .” (v. 7a) “You shall be like a watered garden , whose waters do not fail.” (v. 11c) Scripture: 1 Kings 17:8–16 Purpose: Generosity in fasting opens supernatural provision. 6. The Saint Paul Fast – Revelation & Calling “And the Lord will guide you continually .” (v. 11a) Scripture: Acts 9:9–19 Purpose: Spiritual clarity, vision, and divine assignment. 7. The Ziklag Fast – To Recover What Was Stolen “And satisfy your soul in scorched places.” (v. 11b) Scripture: 1 Samuel 30 Purpose: Restoration of what the enemy has taken. 8. The Daniel Fast – Health, Healing, and Strength “Your healing shall spring forth speedily.” (v. 8b) “And make your bones strong .” (v. 11c) Scripture: Daniel 1:8–20 Purpose: Renew physical strength and health. 9. The John the Baptist Fast – A Pure and Powerful Witness “Then shall your light break forth like the dawn.” (v. 8a) Scripture: Luke 1:15–17 Purpose: Alignment of lifestyle with calling to influence others for Christ. 10. The Esther Fast – Favor, Influence, and Deliverance “And I will make you ride on the heights of the earth .” (v. 14b) Scripture: Esther 4:16 Purpose: God-given influence to bring deliverance to others. 11. The Daniel Fast (Part 2) – Breaking Territorial Strongholds “To break every yoke .” (v. 6d) Scripture: Daniel 10:12–13 Purpose: Spiritual breakthrough over regions and cities. 12. The Antioch Fast – Multiplying Disciples and Churches Scripture: Acts 13 Purpose: To raise leaders and release kingdom multiplication. Practical Tips for Fasting Plan ahead (calendar + family conversations matter). Write down your purpose— aim gives power. The first 36 hours are often emotionally and physically difficult— push through . Let hunger become worship. Reduce intense physical activity. Use Scripture, prayer, journaling, and silence. A Call to Faith and Action Fasting is not about earning something from God—it’s about making space for Him to move. It is the yielding of our strength so His strength can be revealed. The world does not need: more clever sermons more polished ministries more Christian content The world needs Christians who carry the fire of God. So I ask you: What is God calling you to fast for? Freedom? Healing? Revival? Your children? Your city? Your calling? The invitation is simple: Return to hunger. Return to the altar. Return to power. The same God who answered Paul, Elijah, Esther, and Daniel still answers today . Set your fast. Set your faith. Step in. Breakthrough is near.
Fallen Mantles
Hiddenness (Part 2): The Spotlight of Heaven is Shifting
What If the Stories Are True?
What If the Stories Are True?
3 Levels of Guarding We All Need Around Our Heart
How God Designed Your Body to Heal, Thrive, and Glorify Him
Making God’s Presence Our Priority
The Backstory I recently received communication from a family telling me that they were moving and asking if I would be interested in the husband’s father’s library. Before his passing, he had been a revivalist preacher in Texas and avid book collector. I was absolutely thrilled to be the recipient of this collection. As I took the boxes and boxes of books into my office and opened the first case, I was drawn to a small volume entitled Revival: The Need and Possibilities, and started to read. [1] As I began to read this treatise on revival by British clergyman Cyril C.B. Bardsley, the words began to resonate. Although the words were penned 99 years ago in the U.K., it is though they were written last week in the U.S. I’m not saying I stumbled across the Qumran scrolls or the Holy Grail, but I do believe the Lord in his sovereignty led me to this book and I do believe that its pages contain powerful truths for us today. [4] Our hesitancy with Revival: What exactly am I praying for? I think some of our hesitancy to seek revival is that we’re not sure what we’re seeking. Do we mean a week of “special services”? Do we mean a temporary emotional stirring? Do we mean seeing some strange behavior? If we’re gut-level honest, that’s what some people may have in mind when they think of “revival.” And thus, the (understood) hesitancy to ask God for it. But that’s not what revival is! This small book that I came across has the most complete and powerful definition of revival that I have ever seen. So I want to do two things: First, I will summarize some of the important parts of the first chapter and second, I will include a PDF of the first chapter for you to download and read for yourself. [5] For ease of the flow of thought, I have broken Bardsley's thoughts into headings. The headings are mine, but I have included Bardsley’s words underneath verbatim. I will begin with the foreword written by the Bishop of Liverpool which describes the state of the nation and then proceed to Bardsley’s treatise. The State of Our Nation and Need for Renewal Throughout the world there is distress of nations with perplexity. Men’s hearts are failing them for fear, and for looking after those things which are coming on the earth. All the foundations of human society seem out of course. … [The church] is filled with divine dissatisfaction. They are looking for, longing for, and praying for a revival of true religion. Everywhere the prayer is going up, “Come from the four winds, O breath, and breathe upon these slain that they may live.” The history of Christianity from its earliest days until now unfolds the conditions of a great spiritual awakening. When the dissatisfaction which possesses us has found a voice in more fervent and united prayer and has led us to a deeper penitence and renewed trust in God; when self-surrender takes the place of self-will; and prejudice, and suspicion, and jealousy, are lost in love; when we are ready, like Saul of Tarsus, to ask, with heartfelt submission, “What shall I do, Lord?” then the long looked-for revival will come. God will send a gracious rain upon his inheritance and refresh it when it is weary. There will be “showers of blessing,” and a revived Church will awaken the world (7-9). F.J. Liverpool Bishop of Liverpool March 1916